• Latest
  • Trending
New C of E disciplinary process ‘could save £250,000’ and boost legal aid

New C of E disciplinary process ‘could save £250,000’ and boost legal aid

Gates Cambridge Scholarship celebrates 20th anniversary

Gates Cambridge Scholarship celebrates 20th anniversary

Israel-Gaza conflict rages as US envoy visits

Israel-Gaza conflict rages as US envoy visits

Police and Crime Commissioner to end funding for heroin addiction treatment scheme

Police and Crime Commissioner to end funding for heroin addiction treatment scheme

News Press Live
  • Home
  • News
    • All
    • Crime
    • Economy
    • News of England
    • News of Northern Ireland
    • News of Scotland
    • News of Wales
    Gates Cambridge Scholarship celebrates 20th anniversary

    Gates Cambridge Scholarship celebrates 20th anniversary

    Israel-Gaza conflict rages as US envoy visits

    Israel-Gaza conflict rages as US envoy visits

    Police and Crime Commissioner to end funding for heroin addiction treatment scheme

    Police and Crime Commissioner to end funding for heroin addiction treatment scheme

    Nicola Sturgeon’s own economic adviser warns Indyref2 puts recovery at risk

    Nicola Sturgeon’s own economic adviser warns Indyref2 puts recovery at risk

    Horse Racing Getting back on track

    Rochdale hopes machine centre will manufacture revival in fortunes

    The sad state of Cardiff city centre after a year of lockdown as shops lose fight to hold on

    The sad state of Cardiff city centre after a year of lockdown as shops lose fight to hold on

    Convoy drives through London shouting  the Jews, rape their daughters’

    Convoy drives through London shouting the Jews, rape their daughters’

    Conflict intensifies in Gaza as Israeli strikes destroy Gaza tower housing

    Trending Tags

      • Crime
      • Economy
      • News of England
      • News of Northern Ireland
      • News of Scotland
    • Royal Family
    • Tv & Showbiz
    • World News
    • JOBS
    • Sport
      • Football
      • Watch Live Score Football (Soccer) Videos
    • Login
    • Register
    • Latest Headlines
    • Advertise With Us
    • Find A Job
    Monday, January 30, 2023
    Watch Live Sport
    • Home
    • News
      • All
      • Crime
      • Economy
      • News of England
      • News of Northern Ireland
      • News of Scotland
      • News of Wales
      Gates Cambridge Scholarship celebrates 20th anniversary

      Gates Cambridge Scholarship celebrates 20th anniversary

      Israel-Gaza conflict rages as US envoy visits

      Israel-Gaza conflict rages as US envoy visits

      Police and Crime Commissioner to end funding for heroin addiction treatment scheme

      Police and Crime Commissioner to end funding for heroin addiction treatment scheme

      Nicola Sturgeon’s own economic adviser warns Indyref2 puts recovery at risk

      Nicola Sturgeon’s own economic adviser warns Indyref2 puts recovery at risk

      Horse Racing Getting back on track

      Rochdale hopes machine centre will manufacture revival in fortunes

      The sad state of Cardiff city centre after a year of lockdown as shops lose fight to hold on

      The sad state of Cardiff city centre after a year of lockdown as shops lose fight to hold on

      Convoy drives through London shouting  the Jews, rape their daughters’

      Convoy drives through London shouting the Jews, rape their daughters’

      Conflict intensifies in Gaza as Israeli strikes destroy Gaza tower housing

      Trending Tags

        • Crime
        • Economy
        • News of England
        • News of Northern Ireland
        • News of Scotland
      • Royal Family
      • Tv & Showbiz
      • World News
      • JOBS
      • Sport
        • Football
        • Watch Live Score Football (Soccer) Videos
      No Result
      View All Result
      News Press Live
      No Result
      View All Result

      New C of E disciplinary process ‘could save £250,000’ and boost legal aid

      New C of E disciplinary process ‘could save £250,000’ and boost legal aid
      15.4k
      VIEWS
      Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

      THE Ecclesiastical Law Society (ELS) working group that is looking at a replacement for the Clergy Discipline Measure (CDM) produced its final report on Wednesday.

      The working group, chaired by Peter Collier QC, the Vicar-General of York, calculates that its proposed scheme will cost the Church an average of £652,000 p.a. This includes £294,000 to provide legal aid for all respondents accused of serious misconduct.

      The group reckons that the average annual cost of the existing, discredited system under the CDM to be approaching £900,000, with only £104,325 allocated for legal aid (2019 figure).

      The working group predicts a saving even if legal aid is offered in minor as well as serious complaints. This would put the annual legal aid bill at £438,000, making the total cost of dealing with complaints £796,000.

      The chief purpose in forming an ELS working group was concern about injustices of the existing system. These have been acknowledged by another working group chaired by the Bishop at Lambeth, the Rt Revd Tim Thornton (News, 11 December 2020). The final report of the Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse (IICSA) also addressed the issue of clergy discipline and supervision.

      Bishop Thornton’s group, given the task of bringing proposals for a reformed disciplinary to the General Synod, has paid close attention to the deliberations of the ELS group. It has also slowed its own move towards firm proposals in response to calls for greater consultation, not least from the Sheldon Hub, a forum for clergy caught up in the CDM process (News, 12 February)

      Financial savings are just one benefit attributed to the revamped disciplinary system proposed by the ELS, developed from its interim proposals last year (News, 18 September 2020). The working group writes: “We feel confident that we have reached final decisions on a scheme that will enable complaints of all levels of seriousness to be dealt with. We believe that the proposed scheme is one that will not only work, but will deliver what we believe should be at the heart of any such scheme, namely it will enable the Church to live out what the Archbishop of York recently described as a Christ-centred and Jesus-shaped life.”

      In its essence, the proposed ELS scheme begins with an online triage process, which the group calls an assessment process, to be carried out by regional assessors, drawn from the clergy and the laity. Both the complainant and the respondent would be interviewed, plus witnesses if deemed necessary. Minor matters would be identified and dealt with through mediation, or recommendation made to the bishop that they be dismissed, if deemed trivial or vexatious.

      The assessors, for whom training will be given, would be encouraged to attempt to resolve grievances, with minimal involvement of the bishop. In cases of misconduct, both lesser and more serious, the assessor would advise the bishop, who could take appropriate action, acting in the bishop’s “proper role as disciplinarian pastor”. The key element is that the decision on the facts would have been made by the assessor: “the bishop and the cleric will be bound by those facts, subject to the cleric’s right to a review.” The bishop could overrule the assessor’s judgement on the seriousness of the matter, but not the facts.

      For less serious complaints, the working group outlines possible approaches that could, it suggests, involve an element of discipline without damaging the bishop’s pastoral relationship with the respondent.

      Matters of serious misconduct would be referred to a central office for tribunal proceedings. Legal aid at this stage should not be merit- or means-tested, the working group suggests.

      A plea and directions hearing (PDH) would take charge of the timetable to ensure that a trial took place as soon as possible, and certainly within six months. The tribunal members (a legally qualified chair, one lay member and one cleric) would be selected from a panel after a date had been set for the trial rather than as at present, when they are selected first and are then given the task of finding a date that they can all make.

      The working group expects tribunal judgments to be given more publicity than they receive at present, for the sake of transparency and to improve understanding of the principles of clergy conduct. It argues that no time limit should apply when making accusations of serious misconduct, but proposes that the existing 12-month period of limitation remain for less serious offences.

      Cases that follow a conviction in a secular court (section 30 cases) should continue to be fast-tracked, the group says. The power to suspend an accused cleric should be exercised only in the most extreme cases. Political opinions should be exempt from disciplinary proceedings. Matters of doctrine, ritual, and ceremony would need to be dealt with elsewhere.

      Although the working group’s proposals allow for the quick dismissal of vexatious complaints, it admits to having no answer to cases where the complaints process is “weaponised” by unhappy parishioners against a priest. Attempts to resolve such matters are frustrated, the group says, “as it is generally accepted that a bishop has no effective power in relation to lay complainants”.

      The working group’s report contains 16 annexes, including a propose guide to judging the seriousness of a complaint and 20 pages of worked examples, showing how their proposed disciplinary process would work in actual cases, ranging from complaints about a vicar’s children to embezzlement and an allegation of an “unhealthy interest” in members of an adult confirmation class.

      The ELS final report can be found at ecclawsoc.org.uk

      — to www.churchtimes.co.uk

      Share308Tweet193SendSendShare54Pin69

      RelatedPosts

      Gates Cambridge Scholarship celebrates 20th anniversary
      News

      Gates Cambridge Scholarship celebrates 20th anniversary

      Israel-Gaza conflict rages as US envoy visits
      News

      Israel-Gaza conflict rages as US envoy visits

      Police and Crime Commissioner to end funding for heroin addiction treatment scheme
      Crime

      Police and Crime Commissioner to end funding for heroin addiction treatment scheme

      Nicola Sturgeon’s own economic adviser warns Indyref2 puts recovery at risk
      Economy

      Nicola Sturgeon’s own economic adviser warns Indyref2 puts recovery at risk

      London

      Horse Racing Getting back on track

      News

      Rochdale hopes machine centre will manufacture revival in fortunes

      Recommended Stories

      Stormont trying to reach consensus on further coronavirus restrictions

      Stormont trying to reach consensus on further coronavirus restrictions

      RuPaul dedicates fifth Emmy win to late drag queen Chi Chi DeVayne in poignant gesture

      Business events industry campaigns for a roadmap to recovery

      Business events industry campaigns for a roadmap to recovery

      Popular Stories

      • Joe Biden opposes guarded border between Ireland and Northern Ireland | US News

        President Biden Promises to Slash Greenhouse Gas Emissions by 50 Percent by 2030

        2636 shares
        Share 1054 Tweet 659
      • Prince Philip is dead

        2632 shares
        Share 1053 Tweet 658
      • Two US Capitol police officers injured after suspect rams car into barrier and stabbed. Suspect dead

        2372 shares
        Share 949 Tweet 593
      • Prince Harry ‘back in the UK’ ahead of Duke of Edinburgh’s funeral on Saturday

        2143 shares
        Share 857 Tweet 536
      • Juventus chairman Andrea Agnelli says European Super League can no longer go ahead

        2115 shares
        Share 846 Tweet 529
      News Press Live

      © 2021 Copyright - All rights reserved.

      Navigate Site

      • About Us
      • Terms & Conditions
      • Private Policy
      • Advertise With Us
      • Contact Us

      Follow Us

      No Result
      View All Result
      • Home
      • News
        • Crime
        • Economy
        • News of England
        • News of Northern Ireland
        • News of Scotland
      • Royal Family
      • Tv & Showbiz
      • World News
      • JOBS
      • Sport
        • Football
        • Watch Live Score Football (Soccer) Videos

      © 2021 Copyright - All rights reserved.

      Welcome Back!

      Login to your account below

      Forgotten Password? Sign Up

      Create New Account!

      Fill the forms bellow to register

      All fields are required. Log In

      Retrieve your password

      Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

      Log In
      Are you sure want to unlock this post?
      Unlock left : 0
      Are you sure want to cancel subscription?